Home > Complaint Case Studies > I Won My Bank Charge Case: A Case Study

I Won My Bank Charge Case: A Case Study

By: Elizabeth Mugan BA/BSc, PGDipLaw, BVC, CIArb - Updated: 23 Apr 2010 |
Banks Charges Financial Hardship Test

Before the Supreme Court ruled in favour of the banks in the test case in November 2009, many people used to write to the bank stating that their charges were unfair with the reasons why, and asking for their charges to be refunded. In most cases, where the customer threatened to take their case to the Financial Ombudsman or to court, their charges would be refunded almost immediately.

After the test case however, claiming back charges has become much harder and it is expected (although wrongly) that you can never win a case. This case study shows that some people, like Martin, can still manage to claim their charges back.

Financial Circumstances Changed

Martin banked with the Royal bank of Scotland for about 12 years without any problems. However, when he was made redundant in May 2009, he started to get into debt and began to incur bank charges for unpaid bills and going over overdraft limits. By August 2009, he was still unemployed and decided to begin a claim.

Hardship Claim

Martin wrote to the bank describing his hardship situation and claiming that the charges were unfair. He claimed that he was due a refund of £2136.15 in charges. Martin heard nothing for several weeks so he decided to write again. It was this time that the bank sent him a form to fill in about his hardship situation. This is now a guideline by the Financial Ombudsman for the banks to follow, in cases where people are suffering from financial hardship rather than claiming that the charges were illegal.

The form contained spaces to answer questions about income, expenditure, debts and his entire financial situation, and asked him to attach evidence of such hardship. Several weeks after he returned the form, he got a letter from the bank to say they hadn't received it and couldn't consider his case without it, but they didn't include another form. Luckily Martin had copied every document and all correspondence between himself and the bank. Therefore he was able to fire back a copy immediately and this time, sent it by recorded delivery so that the bank would most certainly receive it. The court ruling in the banks favour in the mean time led Martin to think he had ‘missed the boat’ where claiming back charges was concerned and didn’t expect to win a penny.


Martin was surprised when he opened his mail in December 2009, almost two months later and found that the bank had accepted his claim and refunded some of the charges. It was not the full amount he asked for, but it was £1775.00 and much more than he hoped for after the court ruling. He decided to accept the cash, which helped him to clear his most pressing credit card debt and even have a bit left over for Christmas.

Top Tips

Always scan or photocopy everything and post by recorded delivery. It helps you to dodge any stalling tactics employed by companies you are dealing with and can help if the case ever reaches court.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
    Re: Travel and Holiday Regulatory Bodies Complaint
    Our flight was cancelled due to Covid, after hours of waiting on-hold, my refund was granted and confirmed…
    15 July 2020
  • Hickers
    Re: Who You Can Complain to About Landlords
    I am supposed to be moving I to my new rented home in the 20th July. The landlord is an Estate Agency who has…
    13 July 2020
  • Trust GOD
    Re: How to Complain About Your Boss
    I think such complaints must be escalated to HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION and strict action to be taken against such inhuman bosses.
    11 July 2020
  • Josie
    Re: Travel and Holiday Regulatory Bodies Complaint
    Booked flights plus hotel in St Petersburg in early Feb for departure 23 May to 29 with Opodo. Emailed them…
    3 July 2020
  • Nhc
    Re: Who To Complain To
    Left honeymoon couple stranded in turkey and now wont refund our flight money easyjet has paid to them. Next move small claims court. I've…
    2 July 2020
  • Nhc
    Re: Who To Complain To
    Left honeymoon couple stranded in turkey and now wont refund our flight money easyjet has paid to them. Next move small claims court. I've…
    2 July 2020
  • jo1970
    Re: Who To Complain To
    Like many others, I had a holiday booked since 20th January for 30th June to Lanzarote. They insisted on me paying the final balance last…
    23 June 2020
  • MoneyPennie40
    Re: Dealing With Nightmare Housemates
    I've just moved into a 3bed flatshare, since being here, I've noticed 1 of the tenants never seem to clean up after…
    22 June 2020
  • Yanka
    Re: Dealing With Nightmare Housemates
    where I can complain about the inappropriate behavior of a roommate., but we don't know what to do and we are afraid to…
    22 June 2020
    Re: Who To Complain To
    what happens if you do not pay the full balance? I have paid for flights but they have been cancelled. I have emailed proof, and tried calling…
    4 June 2020